Letterboxd Stats showdown: Buster Keaton/Charlie Chaplin

[kanafani]

Every Keaton movie that received a 2.5 star rating (or less):

[kanafani]

Keaton ratings spread:

[kanafani]

Champs sorted by number of Keaton movies logged:

[kanafani]

Champs sorted by average rating of Keaton movies:

[kanafani]

Highest rated Keaton movie for each champ (in case of a tie, I only list one):

[kanafani]

Lowest rated Keaton movie for each champ (in case of a tie, I only list one):

[kanafani]

All ratings for Keaton movies from all champs:

[kanafani]

Combined top 10 from the 2 directors (minimum 2 ratings per movie)

[kanafani]

Combined bottom 10 from the 2 directors (minimum 2 ratings per movie)

[kanafani]

Showdown results. Each champ gets one vote.

[kanafani]

Final score: Chaplin: 5. Keaton: 25

[brian d]

wow, i have the lowest average rating for keaton. i guess it's all those fatty arbuckle movies i watched.

[kanafani]

So...It comes down to Flip and Brian. Flip was the closest to the final score (keaton +9), followed by Brian (+8). However Brian guessed sherlock jr. as the highest-rated Keaton, whereas Flip wagered on our hospitality.

Based on my complicated formula, I declare Brian the winner of this match-up.

[kanafani]

wow, i have the lowest average rating for keaton. i guess it's all those fatty arbuckle movies i watched.

Brian, congratulations on winning this showdown (and on having the lowest average rating for keaton).

You may select the next showdown!

[Curtis, baby]

Awesome, go Buster! Thanks as always kanafani, these are always super insightful. For those that liked Film, Alan Schneider also directed a Beckett script in a filmed play made for TV version of Waiting for Godot, which I can't recommend highly enough. No Buster, but alas...

[brian d]

let's go agnès varda/chantal akerman. seems like they made right around the same number of films, and would probably be competitive.

[kanafani]

let's go agnès varda/chantal akerman. seems like they made right around the same number of films, and would probably be competitive.

Very good. Akerman/varda it is!

[Senor Arkadin]

Ah...
I'm not a big fan of ratings... but I love these. I feel like I've seen a lot of Keaton, and still end up pretty middling in terms of logged films.
I'll probably go temporarily rate Ackerman/Varda for the sake of the next one. Just to try something different.

[kanafani]

I'll probably go temporarily rate Ackerman/Varda for the sake of the next one. Just to try something different.

Excellent idea!

[rischka]

yeah good match, i think akerman wins it but it'll be close