1923 poll

[Lencho of the Apes]

Choose your favorite films from 1923 (according to IMDb).

– Each person votes for up to 20 movies. Do not feel compelled to fill the maximum allowable number, only true favorites.
– Do not rank the films except the number 1, it gets two points..

Users are urged to post their provisional lists as soon as possible so that others may use them for recommendations. You may, of course, revise your lists at any point prior to the deadline.

Ballots posted by people who do not participate in other parts of the forum will not be counted.

Deadline for 1923 lists will be Monday, March 4 at approximately 1 PM Pacific Time.

[Lencho of the Apes]

The never-ending watchlist, titles added as they come available. I hope to note substandard print quality when appropriate, but I haven't done it yet in more than one or two cases.

Adam's Rib - de Mille
Alma De Dios -
Anna Christie
Ashes Of Vengeance
L'Auberge Rouge
Barsoum Looking For A Job -
Black Oxen ////// 1/3 restored, 1/3 not, 1/3 missing
Le Brasiere Ardent -
Broken hearts Of broadway
Cameo Kirby - Ford ///// shoddy print, Portuguese-only titles
Cancao de primavera - Bonfioli
A Clouded Name - Huhn
Coeur Fidele - Epstein
The Covered Wagon - Cruze
Curro Vargas
La dame de Monsoreau - Le Somptier
Defying Destiny
The Desert Rider -
East Side West Side
Die erdgeist -
The Extra Girl
Fraulein Raffke
La fuga di Socrate
The Green Goddess
Grub Stake
Haldane Of The Secrt Service -
Harda Viljor - Brunius
The Hell Ship -
Hunchback Of Notre Dame
INRI -
Johan Ulfstjerna
Koskenlaskijan morsian
La Legende De Soeur beatriz - de baroncelli
Little Church Around The Corner -
Little Old New York -
Os Lobos - Lupo
Lucretia Lombard -
Lulu - de Chomon
Maytime
Merry-Go-Round
North Of Hudson bay -
Oil's Well
Opfer des hasses
Our Hospitality
The Pilgrim - Chaplin
Qiz Qalasi Afsanasi
Raskolnikow/Crime And Punishment - Wiene ///// ugly print with English titles or attractive print, twenty minutes longer, with Russian-only titles.
Red Devils ///// 68 minutes of 130
L Retour A La Raison - man Ray
Rosita - Lubitsch ///// not-good print?
La Roue - Gance
Safety Last - Lloyd
Scaramouche - Ingram
The Shock - /////63 min.s of 96
The Sign Of Four
Silent Command
Souls For Sale
La Souriante madame Beudet -
Die Strass - Grune
The Tango Cavalier
Ten Commandments - de Mille
The Three Ages - Keaton
Tiger Rose /////60 min of 80
The Treasure - Pabst
Warning Shadows
The West-Bound Limited -
Where The North begins
The White Rose - Griffith
White Sister
White Tiger - Browning
A Woman Of Paris - Chaplin
Why Worry
Der Junge Metardus

[kanafani]

This is what I have at the moment. I'll be visiting this space for suggestions:

Cœur fidèle (Jean Epstein, 1923)

Our Hospitality (John G. Blystone, Buster Keaton, 1923)
The Smiling Madame Beudet (Germaine Dulac, 1923)
A Woman of Paris (Charlie Chaplin, 1923)
Three Ages (Edward F. Cline, Buster Keaton, 1923)
Return to Reason (Man Ray, 1923)
Safety Last! (Fred C. Newmeyer, Sam Taylor, 1923)
The Pilgrim (Charlie Chaplin, 1923)

[greennui]

1. Fait-Divers (Claude Autant-Lara)
Cœur fidèle (Jean Epstein)
Return to Reason (Man Ray)
La Roue (Abel Gance)
L'ascension de la Pyramide de "Chéops" par S.A.R. le Prince Léopold
The Smiling Madame Beudet (Germaine Dulac)
Rhythmus 21 (Hans Richter)

[flip]

The Extra Girl (F Richard Jones)

Our Hospitality (Buster Keaton/John Blystone)
Safety Last (Fred Newmeyer/Sam Taylor)
The Shock (Lambert Hillyer)
Horseshoes (Larry Semon/James Davis)
Little Old New York (Sidney Olcott)
The Smiling Madame Beudet (Germaine Dulac)
Return to Reason (Man Ray)
Rhythmus 23 (Hans Richter)

[mesnalty]

The Nightingale's Voice is currently 1925 on IMDb.

[Evelyn Library P.I.]

Does anyone have Per Lindberg's Norrtullsligan sourced?

[greennui]

The Nightingale's Voice is currently 1925 on IMDb.

Shoot.

Does anyone have Per Lindberg's Norrtullsligan sourced?

I'm also curious about this.

[Umbugbene]

1. Warning Shadows (Robison)
2. Raskolnikow (Wiene)
3. Our Hospitality (Keaton)
4. House of Mystery (Volkoff)
5. Brasier Ardent (Moszhukhin)
6. Safety Last! (Newmeyer, Taylor)

[brian d]

i'm torn between our hospitality, coeur fidèle, and the wolves for top spot. almost everything i've seen from this year is good (except for safety last!, because of harold lloyd).

our hospitality (keaton)
coeur fidèle (epstein)
three ages (keaton)
le brasier ardent (mosjoukine)
merry go round (stroheim)
women of the beira (lupo)
the wolves (lupo)
la roue (gance)
the ancient law (dupont)
the smiling madame beudet (dulac)
return to reason (ray)

to see:
warning shadows (robison)
a woman of paris (chaplin)
eld ombord (sjöström)

[sally]

aaaaaaaaaargh this is exciting!!!!

only got 11 from this year, but like them all, even the stan laurel one. but os lobos is fucking amazing. grrr.

so far list in order:

1. os lobos/the wolves (lupo)
eld ombord (sjostrom)
coeur fidele
our hospitality
die lawine (curtiz)
the covered wagon
le brasier ardent
die straße (grune)
der schatz/the treasure (pabst)
frozen hearts
gunnar hede's saga (don't remember a thing about this so going to rewatch)


watchlist: https://letterboxd.com/twodeadmagpies/list/1923-to-see/

[---]

1. Safety Last! (Fred C. Newmeyer/Sam Taylor, 1923) -- 3.5/4
The Pilgrim (Charles Chaplin, 1923) -- 3/4
Our Hospitality (John G. Blystone/Buster Keaton, 1923)

[rischka]

ha i just happen to have a copy of la roue on my 'travel drive'



to watch:

la roue
l'auberge rouge
zaza

i have an unrestored copy of erdgeist but not til the weekend

[karl]

I got six. I've probably seen the Chaplin & Keaton shorts, but too long ago to recall. Tougher choice for the #1 now, since I've recently seen the Sjostrom - wow! - but the great Chaplin's least-seen masterpiece is an old favorite. It's also, if any of you've ever read Anderson & Richie's Japanese Film, one of the faves of the early Japanese directors, especially Ozu.

I'm traveling but should be able to see a few more. For now:

A Woman of Paris
Fire Onboard aka The Hell Ship
Our Hospitality
Gunnar Hedes Saga
Safety Last
Three Ages

All terrific films!

[Roscoe]

OUR HOSPITALITY
NORTULLSLIGAN
ANCIENT LAW

Others will follow, but these are in stone.

[...]

The Smiling Madame Beudet
Our Hospitality
A Woman of Paris
Warning Shadows
The Hunchback of Notre Dame
It's a Gift
Safety Last
La Roue
the Ten Commandments
Rhythm 21
Covered Wagon

Those are the leaders for now maybe I'll add other Keaton, Lloyd, etc. if I don't find more movies I like.

[sally]

Louis Feuillade’s 1923 feature Le Gamin de Paris is likewise unexceptional, though it’s of interest for showing his abandonment of complex staging and his conversion to American-style cutting, including angled shot/reverse-shots. (Of Feuillade’s 1923 installment film Vindicta, we can’t speak; we haven’t been able to see it.)

This from bordwells blog:http://www.davidbordwell.net/blog/2013/ ... s-of-1923/

Their years are all over the place, but if anyone has (subbed) nice copies of le gamin, erdgeist, or raskolnikow, please share!

[---]

I have Raskolnikow. Will post tonight

[sally]

ooooh, thanks

and guys, the nightingale's voice is 1925 on imdb.

[karl]

Anyone have a copy of the restored Das alte Gesetz?

[karl]

The two Chaplins from this year are on Youtube with Spanish titles:

A Woman of Paris
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VWOJm06jNAI

The Pilgrim
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GaahU6HFN4I

[arkheia]

1. La Roue

Cœur fidèle
Three Ages
Rhythmus 21
Our Hospitality
Le retour à la raison
The Extra Girl
La souriante Madame Beudet
Safety Last!

Too busy right now to watch more but hopefully later this month I can catch a few

[MatiasAlbertotti]

The link is to a Playlist I made on Youtube with 70+ movies from 1923 that are available:

Playlist moved to the correct place!!

It's not an exhaustive list, I used Lencho's list at the beginning as guide and then added from what was posted by the rest of the members in their respective lists.

Also, most of the non-english features have spanish subs only, since that's what I found and If spanish subs were available and easy to find I did not look for an english version option. Sorry to all the members that do not understand spanish

If you want to add something to the playlist, let me know.

[mesnalty]

Amazing, thanks Matias!

[sally]

Also, most of the non-english features have spanish subs only, since that's what I found and If spanish subs were available and easy to find I did not look for an english version option. Sorry to all the members that do not understand spanish

secret trick - when there's spanish subs, choose auto-translate to your chosen lang in the subs button - into english it's not perfect, but for the most part quite understandable, esp for silents when there's not much to translate. that peliculas mudas channel is a godsend. don't get it shut down, i've only got about 300 or so left to watch on there!

[Evelyn Library P.I.]

Amazing, thanks Matias!

Indeed!

[karl]

A COUPLE OF DOWN AND OUTS (Walter Summers)

Another one of those PUNQ 1-stars that I quite liked. Simple story: unemployed ex-soldier sees the horse he rode all through the war in a group that's to be sent to the slaughterhouse, so he steals it and hides out in the house of a (naturally) lovely and sympathetic young woman. It is not an exceptionally well-made film, but has a simple charm.

Here's someone who thought even more highly of the film than I did:

"A Couple of Down and Outs" [1923] is the second known film to be directed by Walter Summers, a man who went on to direct a further 36 pictures between 1923 and 1941. Anyone who thought Steven Spielberg’s "War Horse" was lacking a certain je ne sais quoi should definitely give this film a look as it presents the story of an ex-soldier and his war horse with a great deal more power and feeling than last year’s winter blockbuster...
Out of all the many films watched at The British Silent Film Festival, "A Couple of Down and Outs" was undoubtedly the most reverent and moving. The opening sequence, set on Remembrance Day, includes very pointed close-up shots of a war monument engraved with the words ‘The Glorious Dead’, and the endless sea of now-familiar crosses that mark the graves of those lost in the war. Furthermore the film includes some hauntingly realistic depictions of the front line that are sensitively shot, given that this film was released when feelings about the war were still very raw the sensitive handling of its subject matter is a key element of this film’s success. In addition to addressing the difficulty of moving on after the war this film also touches on the economic climate of the time and the moral dilemma nations faced when dealing with animals “broken by the war” covering a lot of scope in its modest run time. (Helen Cox, newempressmagazine.com)

[rischka]

thx from me too mattias as i can't dl at my current location. the hellship was great, toxic masculinity aside :geek: sjostrom has mastered the narrative structure better than anyone this side of dw griffith

[Lencho of the Apes]

Adam's Rib - de Mille, USA

Thematics familiar from other de Mille rom-coms, but there's a proto-Bringing Up Baby subplot that's pretty thrilling in it's prototypicality.

3 ada 2.JPG (62.36 KiB) Viewed 6893 times

3 ada 1.JPG (68.02 KiB) Viewed 6893 times

[sally]

watched henry king's the white sister. looks pretty, ronnie is adorable, but i cannot stand bloody lillian saintly virginal anti-womanflesh-hood child-eyed all suffering gish. so much, that beyond the sadeian justine fantasies such filthy holy mary portrayals of women invoke, i was completely rooting for evil step sister.

but aside from that, lovely film.

and i've got a sodding pickford to sit through yet, just because i love lubitsch....