SCFZ

12 for me too

Seen 5 Vidor's.

1. The Crowd (1928)
2. Show People (1928)

Have 5 Murnau - god, I hate this guy.

yeah, we don't need to check if murnau has the views - murnau will be our next poll! haven't decided yet if i'll start that tomorrow or next week.

Seen 16

1. The Crowd
2. The Big Parade
3. Bardely's the Magnificent
4. Stella Dallas
5. Street Scene

seen 6

The Crowd
Stella Dallas
Bardelys the Magnificent

seen 5 (incl. wizard of oz)
1. Our Daily Bread
2. The Big Parade

scfz seems to have a clear preference for vidor's late 1920s period, though this is the rare poll which features films from the 1920s alongside a film from the 1980s. i guess when we poll manoel de oliveira, the year difference will be even more astounding.

results

1. The Crowd (1928) -- 36 pts
2. The Big Parade (1925) -- 23 pts
3. Bardelys the Magnificent (1926) -- 13 pts
4. Hallelujah (1929) -- 11 pts
5. Street Scene (1931) -- 9 pts
6. The Patsy (1928) -- 7 pts
6. The Fountainhead (1949) -- 7 pts
8. Beyond the Forest (1949) -- 6 pts
8. Our Daily Bread (1934) -- 6 pts
8. Stella Dallas (1937) -- 6 pts
8. Duel in the Sun (1946) -- 6 pts
12. The Wedding Night (1935) -- 5 pts
13. Show People (1928) -- 4 pts
14. Man Without a Star (1955) -- 3 pts
14. The Champ (1931) -- 3 pts
14. The Metaphor: King Vidor meets with Andrew Wyneth (1980) -- 3 pts
14. The Wizard of Oz (1939) -- 3 pts
18. Comrade X (1940) -- 2 pts
18. Wild Oranges (1924) -- 2 pts
18. Ruby Gentry (1952) -- 2 pts
18. Solomon and Sheba (1959) -- 2 pts
18. La Boheme (1926) -- 2 pts
23. War and Peace (1956) -- 1 pt

posted to letterboxd:

https://letterboxd.com/fliptrotsky/list ... -poll-139/