SCFZ

Final list, 5 tiers:

Mount Fuji - The Movement of Clouds (Masanao Abe)
The Love Parade (Ernst Lubitsch)

Black and Tan (Dudley Murphy)
Arabesque (Germaine Dulac)

Liberty (Leo McCarey)
Man With a Movie Camera (Dziga Vertov)

Lucky Star (Frank Borzage)
Big Business (Leo McCarey)

Un Chien Andalou (Luis Buñuel)
Sound Test for Blackmail (Alfred Hitchcock)

I'm sure Lubitsch made better musicals than The Love Parade and I'm not usually a nostalgic fella, but I can't help it, the first and only time I've seen this film was quite memorable for me. It was at a national film festival where I also got to meet Kiarostami and even asked him to sign my copy of Copie Conforme as if he was some kind of Hollywood star (younger me could be such an idiot). Simple times.

Flight is hilarious. i'm dying over here

i'll get my list together tmrw

For my last film of the poll, I decided to revisit Wild Orchids (Sidney Franklin) since I didn't enjoy it too much the first go around. A second viewing improved my opinion of it somewhat; the orientalist ideas and Nils Asther as an exotic Javanese prince are still repellant but the way the film toes the line between the insecurities of Garbo's husband Lewis Stone and the ambivalent fantasies of Garbo are more complicated than initially apparent. Won't be adding it to my list but I liked wrapping this poll up by rewatching something to see if my opinions on it significantly changed.

doing all the not-even-on-imdb stuff now (our man j c mol doesn't seem to have anything for 1929 but he was filmhand on a dick laan short about a boy with tuberculosis, the tulip time-lapse is very telling)

but the dutch still at it - there's a nice short about electricity in the hague on EYE by otto van neijenhoff, and of course willy mullens has made a million

and in the uk there's a whole 90 min doc about british docks...and a short that does all the sights of england in 11 mins...

I guess I'll submit a list. Just make it unranked to make it easier (all except one has the same rating anyways)

A Dança dos Paroxismos - Jorge Brum do Canto
Человек с киноаппаратом [Man With a Movie Camera] - Dziga Vertov
Die Büchse der Pandora [Pandora's Box] - G.W. Pabst
Erotikon [Seduction] - Gustav Machatý
Histoire de détective [Detective Story] - Charles Dekeukeleire
Jenseits der Straße [Harbour Drift] - Leo Mittler
The Love Parade - Ernst Lubitsch
La perle [The Pearl] - Henri d' Ursel
Varhaník u sv. Víta [The Organist at St. Vitus' Cathedral] - Martin Frič
Die weiße Hölle vom Piz Palü [The White Hell of Pitz Palu] - Arnold Fanck / G.W. Pabst
Новый Вавилон [The New Babylon] - Григорий Козинцев [Grigori Kozintsev] / Леонид Трауберг [Leonid Trauberg]
Турксиб [Turksib] - Viktor Turin
Хліб [Bread] - Mykola Shpykovskyi
ჩემი ბებია [My Grandmother] - Kote Miqaberidze

Me list now today me post. [/Koko syntax] So many I couldn't get to!

Arsenal - Dovzhenko
A Cottage On Dartmoor -Asquith
Old And New/The General Line - Eisenstein
Man With A Movie Camera - Vertov

The Living Corpse/Zhivoy trup - Fyodor Otsep
Maman Colibri - Duvivier
The Manxman
Piccadilly - E A Dupont

Gardiens De Phare - Gremillon
Le Capitain Fracasse
A dança dos paroxismos (Jorge Brum do Canto)
Hallelujah - King Vidor

Histoire De Detective - Charles Dekeukelaire
Pour Tes Beaux Yeux -
The Love Parade- Lubitsch
Lucky Star -Borzage

Blackmail-Hitchcock
Hell's Heroes-Wyler
Linda - Dorothy Davenport
The Skeleton Dance- Disney

lucky star
the love parade
a cottage on dartmoor
woman in the moon

erotikon
pandora's box
gardiens de phare
the new babylon

fraulein else
finis terrae
the living corpse
arsenal

man with a movie camera
asphalt
peau de peche
the wonderful lies of nina petrovna

thunderbolt
la perle
two-buldi-two
laila

Note for thoxans: gardiens de phare = the lighthouse keepers

Do I have time to watch something today, Thoxans?

How come Jaques Catelain wasn't in Maman Colibri? My 1929 Experience feels incomplete somehow.

The New Babylon
The General Line
Woman in the Moon
White Hell of Pitz Palu
Flight

Erotikon
Sevil
Eternal Heart
The Pearl
Sunnyside Up

Pandora's Box
Lucky Star
A Strong Man
The Love Parade
In Spring

The Organist at St. Vitus’ Cathedral
The Last Performance
Wrong Again
My Grandmother
The Manxman

Arsenal
Den Starkaste
The Manxman
Un Chien Andalou

Eternal Love
Maman Colibri
The Night Coachman (Tasin)
Turksib

La Femme et le Pantin
Lucky Star
Heart's Triumph
2-buldi-2

The Sins of Love (Lamac)
Spite Marriage
The Last Attraction (Preobrazhenskaya & Pravov)
In Spring (Kaufman)

Peau de Peche
The Virginian
Hell's Heroes
Thunderbolt

Laptop died & I'm travelling, so didn't get to see much.

will have this one tallied up tomorrow evening, so late/updated ballots will be welcome until then!

final results (lmk if anything looks amiss)

man with a movie camera | 35.5
Lucky Star | 34
The Love Parade | 31.5
a cottage on dartmoor | 30.5
The New Babylon | 28
the lighthouse keepers | 27
the white hell of pitz palu | 27
Arsenal | 26
Pandora's Box | 25
Autumn Mists | 23
Erotikon | 22.5
Un Chien Andalou | 22
finis terrae | 18.5
the living corpse | 18
Woman in the Moon | 18
The Pearl | 17
The Manxman | 15
In Spring | 14.5
The General Line | 14
Eternal Love | 12.5
Harbor Drift (Mittler) | 12
laila | 12
Liberty (Leo McCarey, USA) | 12
Arabesque | 11.5
Fragment of an Empire (Ermler) | 11.5
Peach Skin | 11.5
Rain | 11.5
Applause (Rouben Mamoulian, 1929) | 11
A Dança dos Paroxismos - Jorge Brum do Canto | 11
My Grandmother | 11
Mother Krause's Journey to Happiness (Jutzi) | 10.5
mount fuji - the movement of clouds | 10.5
Blackmail | 10
fraulein else | 10
The Triumph of the Heart (Gustaf Molander) | 13
the way of lost souls | 10
the wonderful lies of nina petrovna | 10
asphalt | 9.5
Black and Tan (Dudley Murphy) | 9.5
Diary of a Lost Girl (1929, Georg Wilhelm Pabst) | 9
La Femme et le Pantin | 9
Histoire De Detective - Charles Dekeukelaire | 9
Piccadilly - E A Dupont | 9
Turksib | 9
Two Pence Magic (Hans Richter) | 9
The Organist at St. Vitus' Cathedral] - Martin Frič | 8.5
Maman Colibri | 8
Big News (Gregory La Cava) | 7.5
captain fracasse | 7.5
Spite Marriage | 7.5
Impressions of the Old Harbor of Marseilles (Vieux Port) (László Moholy-Nagy) | 7
the informer | 7
Big Business (James W. Horne / Leo McCarey) | 6.5
Sunny Side Up (David Butler) | 6.5
For Your Beautiful Eyes (Henri Storck, 1929) | 6
Saint Joan the Maid) | 6
Den Starkaste | 5
H2O (Ralph Steiner) | 5
King of the Rodeo (Henry MacRae, 1929) | 5
Thunderbolt | 5
Ethnographic Films (Zora Neale Hurston) | 4.5
Fight of the Tertia" (Max Mack, Germany) | 4.5
Flight | 4.5
Hell's Heroes | 4.5
Melody of the Heart" (Hanns Schwarz, Germany) | 4.5
The Mysterious Island (Lucien Hubbard/Benjamin Christensen/Maurice Tourneur, USA) | 4.5
2-buldi-2 | 4
Bulldog Drummond (F Richard Jones) | 4
Dans la nuit (1929, Charles Vanel) | 4
Spring in Subcarpathian Ruthenia (Karel Plicka) | 4
The Cocoanuts (Robert Florey and Joseph Santley) | 4
The Gypsy Charmer (Valentin Vaala) | 4
The Kingdom of Rye (Ivar Johansson) | 4
The Night Coachman (Tasin) | 4
The Sins of Love (Karel Lamač) | 4
A Straightforward Boy (Yasujirō Ozu) | 3.5
Blackmail [silent version] (Alfred Hitchcock, UK) | 3.5
Desert Nights (William Nigh) | 3.5
Disque 957 (Germaine Dulac) | 3.5
Eternal Heart | 3.5
Sevil | 3.5
Taro’s Toy Train (Yasuji Murata) | 3.5
The Hole in the Wall (Robert Florey) | 3.5
The Skeleton Dance (Walt Disney, USA) | 3.5
The Woman One Longs For" (Kurt Bernhardt, Germany) | 3.5
A Throw of Dice (Franz Osten, 1929) | 3
Bread] - Mykola Shpykovskyi | 3
brüder | 3
Dynamite | 3
Fue no shiratama [Undying Pearl] (Hiroshi Shimizu) | 3
Hallelujah - King Vidor | 3
Lady of the Pavements | 3
Linda - Dorothy Davenport | 3
sangue mineiro | 3
Skyscraper Symphony (Robert Florey) | 3
sprengbagger 1010 | 3
The Letter (de Limur) | 3
The New Gentlemen) | 3
The Shakedown (Wyler) | 3
Tokyo March (Kenji Mizoguchi) | 3
Where East Is East | 3
Wild Orchids | 3
A Pair of Tights (Hal Yates) | 2.5
A Strong Man | 2.5
Border Romance (Richard Thorpe) | 2.5
Seven Keys to Baldpate (Reginald Barker) | 2.5
Sound Test for Blackmail (Alfred Hitchcock) | 2.5
The Blue Express" (Ilya Trauberg, Soviet Union) | 2.5
Adieu Mascotte (1929, Wilhelm Thiele) | 2
Drifters (1929, John Grierson) | 2
Images d'Ostende (Henri Storck) | 2
Nogent, Eldorado du Dimanche (Marcel Carne) | 2
Pour Tes Beaux Yeux - | 2
Queen Kelly (1929, Erich von Stroheim) | 2
Rayon de soleil (1929, Jean Gourguet & Georges Péclet) | 2
The Last Attraction (Preobrazhenskaya & Pravov) | 2
Today (1929, Esfir Shub) | 2
Tusalava (Len Lye) | 2
Bouncing Babies (Robert F. McGowan) | 1.5
Going Ga-Ga (Hal Yates) | 1.5
Mother Hummingbird" (Julien Duvivier, France) | 1.5
Our Modern Maidens (Jack Conway, USA) | 1.5
The Flying Scotsman (Castleton Knight) | 1.5
The Last Performance | 1.5
Wrong Again | 1.5
Fighting Friends (Yasujiro Ozu) | 1
The Iron Mask (Allan Dwan) | 1
The Virginian | 1

A Dança dos Paroxismos - Jorge Brum do Canto | 9
The Dance of the Paroxysms (Jorge Brum do Canto) | 2

Maman Colibri | 8
Mother Hummingbird" (Julien Duvivier, France) | 1.5

thx for yr work thoxans. should i preserve these polls? i thought i had original '29 but damned if i can find it. earliest one i have is 1960 (6 yrs ago)

same i think..

Autumn Mists | 18
Brumes D'Automne (Dimitri Kirsanoff) | 5

Rain | 8.5
Regen (Joris Ivens / Manaus Franken) | 3

The General Line | 9
Old And New/The General Line - Eisenstein | 5

Histoire De Detective - Charles Dekeukelaire | 6
Detective Story] - Charles Dekeukeleire | 3

Erotikon | 19.5
Seduction] - Gustav Machatý | 3

thoxans wrote: ↑Fri Jul 02, 2021 9:34 pm The Triumph of the Heart (Gustaf Molander) | 10
Heart's Triumph | 3

La Femme et le Pantin | 6
The Woman and the Puppet) | 3

Maybe we should stick to the letterboxd titles of the films in order to make it easier for thoxy?

noted on all, and updated accordingly! thx