Doubling the Canon 2020 Update - Results

[Angel]

Testing, testing...

[Angel]

RESULTS (ongoing)

Google Docs

ICMForum

[Mauries]

0.5 mm

[rischka]

yay gubben i stugen! also ofrene has got dead souls and a vingança de uma mulher and is beating everyone else

Probably confusing to those at ICM who don't know we exist

[MrCarmady]

I got my first one on straight away, the lovely 4 Aventures, and it's all been downhill since. Happy Duck Amuck made it because it seems like the stuff with more views is generally disadvantaged by the voting system.

[ofrene]

Surprised none of voters saw Beed-o baad, small Iranian masterpiece written by Kirostami

and all the love for Bi Gan.. that's unexpected

[Angel]

yay gubben i stugen! also ofrene has got dead souls and a vingança de uma mulher and is beating everyone else

Probably confusing to those at ICM who don't know we exist

Actually the most successful player this year was not ofrene, but another fellow member of this forum...

[rischka]

Is it Brian d?

[greennui]

My bet is on Mauries

[Mauries]

I got 2 out of 8 so far

Gaetmaeul 3.23 / 14
Het Oog Boven de Put 4.67 / 9
Katzelmacher 3.00 / 36
La Casa Lobo 4.06 / 17
Les Doigst dans la Tête 3.71 / 7
Ragbar 3.22 / 10
Stella Dallas 3,38 / 28
Stage Door 3,89 / 39

I only submitted 10 films though..

[brian d]

Is it Brian d?

the only one i saw so far got 3 votes for a solid 2.0 rating. doubt it's me.

[greennui]

All but one of my nominations have appeared so far. I've done a lot better in previous years but ah well.

1. 0.5 mm (Momoko Andô, 2014) 3,90 11
2. Baal (Volker Schlöndorff, 1970) 3,31 17
3. Central Bazaar (Stephen Dwoskin, 1976) 3,17 6
4. Drift (Helena Wittmann, 2017) 3,64 12
5. The Old Man in the Cottage (Nina Hedenius, 1995) 4,50 8
6. Kestrel's Eye (Mikael Kristersson, 1998) 5,33 3
7. Fire Woman (Kim Ki-young, 1971) 2,89 9
8. The Tiniest Place (Tatiana Huezo, 2011) 4,60 5
9. Céline (Jean-Claude Brisseau, 1992) 3,76 18
10. Hill of Freedom (Hong Sang-soo, 2014) 3,41 18
11. The Leaden Echo and the Golden Echo (Margaret Tait, 1955)
12. L'eau de la Seine (Téo Hernandez, 1983) 3,75 13

The Tiniest Place very much feels like a SCFZ film, in fact, I think learned of it from the 2010's poll though no SCFZ'ers I follow on letterboxd have watched it, unless N Vermelho is one, can't remember.

[rischka]

The Tiniest Place very much feels like a SCFZ film, in fact, I think learned of it from the 2010's poll though no SCFZ'ers I follow on letterboxd have watched it, unless N Vermelho is one, can't remember.

this can't possibly be as i can't remember ever hearing about it. unless it was blueboy

ha i think you're right abt mauries

[greennui]

Simone Barbès ou la vertu (Marie-Claude Treilhou) 4,40 5

I think one or two people didn't vote this time around cuz I remember watching it last year and thinking my vote would def help put it in next year's dtc. Ah well, still a holdover.

[ofrene]

done with this year.. 2/12 same as last year

A Vingança de Uma Mulher (Rita Azevedo Gomes, 2012) 4.31, 14
Beed-o baad (Mohammad-Ali Talebi, 1999) 5,00, 1
Dead Souls (Bing Wang, 2018) 4,22, 9
Dusty Stacks of Mom: The Poster Project (Jodie Mack, 2013) 3,67, 9
Girlfriends (Claudia Weill, 1978) 3,50, 37
Goryeo jang (Ki-young Kim, 1963) 3,50, 6
Hotarubi (Heinosuke Gosho, 1958) 3,60, 5
Hyuil (Man-hui Lee, 1968) 3,21, 15
Maeumui gohyang (Yong-Gyu Yoon, 1949) 3,20, 16
Obaltan (Hyun-mok Yoo, 1961) 3,26, 29
Palwolui Keuriseumaseu (Jin-ho Hur, 1998) 2,81, 17
The Pirate (Vincente Minnelli, 1948) 3,89, 20

[Mauries]

3 out of 10 in the end, great score

Gaetmaeul 3.23 / 14
Het Oog Boven de Put 4.67 / 9
Katzelmacher 3.00 / 36
La Casa Lobo 4.06 / 17
Les Doigst dans la Tête 3.71 / 7
Ragbar 3.22 / 10
Stella Dallas 3,38 / 28
Stage Door 3,89 / 39
Time Indefinite 4,21 / 15
The Queen of Spades 2,87 / 33

[MrCarmady]

done with this year.. 2/12 same as last year

Girlfriends (Claudia Weill, 1978) 3,50, 37

If it makes you feel better, I've had it on my to-watch list for ages, this was the final push and it's probably the best thing I've watched this year.

[Silga]

My nominations by highest rating:

1. The Heart Is a Lonely Hunter (Robert Ellis Miller, 1968) 3.85 [14]
2. The Naked Kiss (Samuel Fuller, 1964) 3.76 [59]
3-4. Hyènes (Djibril Diop Mambéty, 1992) 3.68 [42]
3-4. They Drive by Night (Raoul Walsh, 1940) 3.68 [34]
5. I Served the King of England (Jirí Menzel, 2006) 3.5 [11]
6. The Last Days of Disco (Whit Stillman, 1998) 3.48 [30]
7. The Grey Fox (Phillip Borsos, 1982) 3.40 [46]
8. Affliction (Paul Schrader, 1997) 3.31 [28]
9. Lovers of the Arctic Circle (Julio Medem, 1998) 3.18 [37]
10. The Reflecting Skin (Philip Ridley, 1990) 3.04 [25]
11. Prometheus (Ridley Scott, 2012) 2.16 [64]

[Angel]

DtC 2020 IMDB List

I'll update the Letterboxd list in the coming days.

Thanks to all who contributed!

[Mauries]

Thank you Angel for all the work!

[Angel]

Letterboxd list updated

[ofrene]

done with this year.. 2/12 same as last year

Girlfriends (Claudia Weill, 1978) 3,50, 37

If it makes you feel better, I've had it on my to-watch list for ages, this was the final push and it's probably the best thing I've watched this year.

glad you liked it!

Also thanks Angel for doing all these work!

[brian d]

this is a pretty impressive result right here:

Arabella, mereröövli tütar 1983 Peeter Simm brian d 2.00 3
Cantando dietro i paraventi 2003 Ermanno Olmi brian d 2,89 9
Cheriyachante Kroora Krithyangal 1979 John Abraham brian d 3,00 4
Insan 1994 Ibrahim Shaddad brian d 2,63 8
La mancha de sangre 1937 Adolfo Best-Maugard brian d 3,11 10
L'Atlantide 1921 Jacques Feyder brian d 3,46 14
Mueda, Memoria e Massacre 1979 Ruy Guerra brian d 2,00 5
Naisenkuvia 1970 Jörn Donner brian d 1,57 7
Nirmalyam 1973 M.T. Vasudevan Nair brian d 2,60 5
Os Lobos 1923 Rino Lupo brian d 2,60 11
Zhong lie tu 1975 King Hu brian d 3,60 11

[flip]

this is a pretty impressive result right here:

i didn't do any better

[MrCarmady]

Oh yeah, thanks Angel!

4 aventures de Reinette et Mirabelle 1987 3.94 37
Amateur 1994 3.30 22
Az én XX. századom 1989 3.76 42
Barcelona 1994 3.38 26
Do lok tin si 1995 3.70 52
Giù la testa 1971 3.18 49
Il tuo vizio è una stanza chiusa e solo io ne ho la chiave 1972 2.65 22 - ouch
Liebe ist kälter als der Tod 1969 3.04 30
Speed Racer 2008 2.48 32 - double ouch but not as surprising
Times Square 1980 3.80 11
Vampire's Kiss 1988 2.91 36 - triple ouch but also not surprising really
Wonderland 1999 3.00 13

The Moyle, the WKW, and the Enyedi all did well but just not well enough, disappointingly, while the Rohmer scraped in, thankfully. Need to re-evaluate my strategy for next time for sure, although the one that made it in is one of the more widely seen ones, weirdly.