Letterboxd Stats showdown: jimmy Stewart / John Wayne

[kanafani]

Wayne rating spread:

[kanafani]

Champs sorted by number of Wayne movies they've logged:

[kanafani]

Champs sorted by average Wayne rating:

[kanafani]

Highest rated Wayne movie for each champ (in case of a tie, I only list one):

[kanafani]

Lowest rated Wayne movie for each champ (in case of a tie, I only list one):

[sally]

you see this is why i don't rate movies any more. madness!

[kanafani]

All Wayne ratings from all champs:

[kanafani]

James Stewart

• Average Rating: 3.78
• Total Champ Views: 619
• Total Champ Ratings: 458
• Highest Rated Movie: Vertigo (4.60 stars, 24 ratings)
• Lowest Rated Movie: Airport-77 (2 stars, 2 ratings)

[kanafani]

Breakdown of Stewart movies, sorted by highest average SCFZ rating:

[kanafani]

Breakdown of Stewart movies, sorted by number of logs:

[kanafani]

Notes on divisive Stewart movies:

[kanafani]

Every Stewart movie that received a 2.5 star rating (or less):

[kanafani]

Stewart ratings spread:

[kanafani]

Champs sorted by number of Stewart movies logged:

[kanafani]

Champs sorted by Stewart average rating:

[kanafani]

Highest rated Stewart movie for each champ (in case of a tie, I only list one):

[kanafani]

Lowest rated Stewart movie for each champ (in case of a tie, I only list one):

[kanafani]

All ratings from all Stewart movies:

[kanafani]

Combined top 10 highest rated movies from both actors:

[kanafani]

Combined top 10 lowest rated from both actors

[kanafani]

Each champ gets one vote. Your vote goes to the actor you rated higher.

[kanafani]

It is a tie. 16-16.

[Curtis, baby]

thanks kanafani!!! BEST SHOWDOWN YET!!! Loved looking through all of this

but seriously, yall NEED to check out Come Live With Me

[rischka]

OMG IT'S A TIE that's cool since i love both of them

sry i didn't have many ratings just many ♥♥♥

[kanafani]

gregx, you get to choose the next showdown!

[thoxans]

while it wouldn't have altered the final results, i really should give jimmy's harvey a 4, instead of a 3. after all, it is the film that made me realize how fun alcoholism could be

[...]

Wow, that's a lot of work you put in kanafani. Thanks! Sorry about adding all the extra effort added from my ratings.

Do you want to do another actor comp or go back to directors?

[...]

Oh, and in case anyone is wondering about that Tycoon rating, I wouldn't actually recommend it since most people don't like it at all and my interest in it is as much a meta-fascination as anything else. It's made by a director, Richard Wallace, that I think is unusual, it has a bit of an odd Wayne role where he's both hero and villain in turns, and it's kinda excessive in an interesting way, artistically and politically. The few other people who've seen it that I've found don't like it much at all.

But Film: 76379 is definitely worth a view. Totally underrated. Heh.

[kanafani]

Do you want to do another actor comp or go back to directors?

It’s really up to you!

[...]

All right then with actors there's no excuse for leaving women out, so let's start with similar battle for them. Bette Davis and Barbara Stanwyck should have enough movies viewed to be interesting.

(By convention, it should be Crawford vs Davis and maybe something like Rogers vs Stanwyck, but I don't know if Crawford and Rogers would have adequate viewings of a lot of their movies.)