SCFZ

Champs sorted by average rating of Dietrich movies:

Highest rated Dietrich movie for each champ (in case of a tie, I only list one):

Lowest rated Dietrich movie for each champ (in case of a tie, I only list one):

All ratings for Dietrich movies from all champs:

Combined top 10 from the 2 actresses (minimum 2 ratings per movie)

Combined bottom 10 from the 2 actresses (minimum 2 ratings per movie)

Showdown results. Each champ gets one vote.

The final score is Garbo: 7. Dietrich: 24.

Dietrich wins in a bloodbath (+17).

Best guess was from john ryan (+16). He picked this showdown, so he gets bragging rights, but the runner-up gets to pick the next showdown.

Runner-up is rischka

rischka wrote: ↑Wed Feb 27, 2019 6:59 pmfair nuff

rischka, congratulations for winning the showdown. You get to pick the next one. Director-versus-director works. Actor-versus-Actor works. Showdowns are gender-neutral. The sky is the limit.

what??! i won?? i'll have to think about what to choose. i'll have something by tmrw :geek:

I'm just pleased Garbo got seven. I was worried she wouldn't get any at all. Tough competing against someone who worked with so many top level directors when she alone was often the dominant reason to watch her films. There aren't many actors who so warp the texture of their films like Garbo did, pulling everything else towards her. Davis might be close, but in an entirely different, more aggressively demanding, manner.

greg x wrote: ↑Sat Mar 02, 2019 12:41 am she alone was often the dominant reason to watch her films.

Very true, which explains why i’ve only seen a pitiful 3 movies starring Garbo. I tend to choose what movies to watch based on who directed them as opposed who starred in them.

so i was gonna say chaplin vs keaton but that's too easy right

what about laurel and hardy vs the marx brothers?!

rischka wrote: ↑Sat Mar 02, 2019 9:18 pm so i was gonna say chaplin vs keaton but that's too easy right

what about laurel and hardy vs the marx brothers?!

Chaplin/Keaton sounds good! Shall we go with that?

ok that'll work. wasn't sure we hadn't done that already!

dammit! rischka one-upped me with the price-is-right stategy. now i know how it feels to be outbid by one dollar...

2 (technical) wins in a row for me. I wish I could translate my gambling luck here into the physical realm!